Sunday, 16 May 2010

Are the Films of The Coens of the Film Noir Persuasion?


I watched Blood Simple, and i have to be honest, i wasn't exactly blown away by it. There were elements of the film that i thought were actually quite good, but it had a very strange soundtrack and it was quite constant as well. In scenes where the music was non-diegetic there was really strange (very 80's) ominous music whirring away in the background, which in my opinion really cheapened the film and ruined it slightly. This is interesting to look at in a huge dramatic comparison to No Country for Old Men when they made the artistic decision to keep the soundtrack incredible minimal. There are only a couple of scenes where there is music and silence helps in building tension, setting the scene and focusing your attention on the action, not the music.

Thematically, Blood Simple as their first film, was arguably in the Film Noir style. This has been an ongoing stylistic choice by the Coen Brothers and was incredibly present in Barton Fink, The Big Lebowski No Country for Old Men, Burn After Reading etc. Although some of these films may not visually abide by the style of Film Noir the themes are certainly there. For example:

Barton Fink - there was the crime, where Audrey Taylor was murdered, and the suspicious and strange next door neighbour Charlie Meadows. Then in true noir style, a regular man gets drawn into the crime almost against his will, Barton Fink just happens to find the murdered woman in his own bed and his next door neighbour just so happens to be a prime suspect.

The Big Lebowski - the crime was the two men mistook one Jeff Lebowski for another and urinated on his rug. All he wanted to do was get a new rug, but then was dragged into the mystery of the the other Jeff Lebowski's missing wife. Again, a regular man, dragged into the crime against his will.

No Country for Old Men - A man stumbles upon a crime scene in the desert involving several dead Mexicans and case full of money. He takes the money and is then hunted down, hes just a regular man, although this one arguable could be self inflicted, not so much against his own will.
Burn After Reading - This ones a tricky one since the whole point of the film is that there actually never was a crime to begin with but Linda and Chad (MacDormand and Pitt) were convinced there was which leads to a death, getting Russians involved, divorces etc.



Some of these films when asked "What kind of style would you say No Country for Old Men has?" you wouldn't initially say "Oh yes, definitely Film Noir" you would probably say that it was a Western, purely on its location, or maybe even a thriller because of all the chase scenes and deaths. It is both of those things but it also follows the traits of a film noir film.

Another common occurrence in film noir is that the main protagonists are not usually clean cut characters and tend to be running away from something or some past infliction that is haunting them. This is also very true to Coen Brothers film, Barton Fink is suffering from writers block after having a big hit play, Ray and Abby in Blood Simple are having an affair, Linda in Burn After Reading has all kinds of issues with her body and relationships, the 3 men of Oh Brother Where art Thou are convicts, The Dude in The Big Lebowski is unemployed, has no money and just drinks and bowls all day. The list goes on and on, but you can apply this to almost every single protagonist created by the Coen Brothers.

I think i can safely say, after a fair bit of film watching and deliberation, the films of the Coen Brothers have a touch of Film Noir in them, some films stronger than others!

http://www.wikipedia.com/
http://www.imdb.com/
http://www.coenbrothers.net/
Blood Simple, Dir. Joel Coen, 1984
Silver, A, Ursini, J, Duncan, P (2004). Film Noir. Italy: Taschen. 12 - 15.

1 comment:

  1. OK Ellie, this has the makings of an interesting study but there is nowhere near enough academic/theoretical research on auteurs, genre or the Coens themselves. You need to correct this if you want to do well; at the moment there's too much conjecture and unsubstantiated opinion. The formatting, proofreading, and references all need substantial attention to. Please make sure you attend this week's tutorial so we can rectify this.

    ReplyDelete